St Michael’s College / Mariel O’Neill-Karch

Like the province of Quebec, St Michael’s College underwent, in the sixties and early seventies, a form of “quiet revolution.” Several priests and sisters left their communities, the laity were called upon to play a greater role, and women were admitted to what had previously been all-male bastions. Coupled with these changes was a major demographic explosion (the number of students enrolled at St Michael’s more than doubled, from 889 in 1959-60 to 2,074 in 1971-72), which meant that new staff had to be hired to meet the demand. In the Department of French, though the increase was dramatic – from eleven full-time members in 1959-60 to a high of nineteen in 1971-72 – the student-faculty ratio actually rose and continued to be greater than that of French departments at the other colleges. The number of students remained high (2,114 in 1975-76), but

down



fiscal considerations forced a drop in the number of full-time members of the department to fifteen, just before the creation of the University Department in 1975.

Ever conscious of the challenges posed by these numbers was Richard B. Donovan, who served as head during these heady times, having succeeded his former professor, Father Bondy, in 1962. Father Donovan knew St Michael’s well; he had been an undergraduate student in the forties and the college gold medalist in French. The 1946-47 college yearbook gives a glimpse of his prospects: “’Slick Dick’ is a fisherman by hobby. After a four-year battle he has succeeded in hooking a big, juicy B.A. With his line the future sees him landing many more catches.”2 Indeed, he does not seem to have had any trouble landing more degrees, earning his ma in French from the University of Toronto and his

down up



PhD from Yale University in 1956, with a thesis, written under the supervision of Erich Auerbach, on the relationship of Spanish and French medieval liturgical drama, later published by the Pontifical Institute under the title The Liturgical Drama in Mediaeval Spain (1958). This contribution to scholarship earned him, in 1960, the title of corresponding fellow of the Real Academia de Buenas Letras de Barcelona.

Father Richard B. Donovan, St Michael's college Head 1962-75

If Father Donovan was admired abroad for his specialized knowlege of medieval drama, he is best remembered at the college for his unfailing qualities as an administrator and a teacher. His colleague Father Kevin Kirley has attested:

Fr. Donovan was the head of our small French department at smc,

down up



and he ran it with both efficiency and understanding. He was always available in his office to listen to the woes of young teachers like myself and offer suggestions, available not only to the members of his department but to the students as well, and that late into the night, every night ... He, too, enjoyed teaching French grammar, so we frequently discussed idiomatic uses of this and that and how best it could be taught. Fr. Donovan, while kind to all the professors, always kept the good of the undergraduate students in mind. They were the ones who mattered most in the university, the university existed for them.3

Father Donovan’s concern for students and his awareness of the fact that if the rapport between the students and the professor is good in the first year, these students are likely to continue to be affiliated with the department, led him to put his best teachers, including himself, in charge of large first-year classes. He

down up



worried, in the late sixties, when some of these teachers (Fink, Fitting, Holmes, O’Neill, entre autres) went on regular skiing expeditions – he felt that tennis was dangerous enough – that the foundation of his academic programme would be compromised. But the daredevil skiers always returned safely to their classrooms. In 1977 Father Donovan accepted an appointment as college registrar. Though this position left him little time to teach, he did, until 1984, continue to give one first-year course and used his new position to steer students into what he still considered to be an excellent French programme. After he left the post of registrar in 1988, he continued to serve the college and its former students through his work with the director of Alumni Affairs.

Others who, like Father Donovan, came on staff during the fifties, did much to

down up



shape the department in the following decade. For Sister M. Corinne (Mary Kathleen Meraw), life was “de la musique avant toute chose.” She was a gifted pianist and organist and acquired her first degree at the University of Toronto in Honours Music. At the Ontario College of Education, she prepared a specialist’s certificate in Music under the late Dr Leslie Bell, “who thought so highly of her abilities that on at least one occasion when he was forced to miss some classes, he asked her to substitute for him as teacher.”4 But in 1946, when her career as a teacher of music was just beginning, tragedy struck. While taking her turn in the laundry room, she caught her left hand in a steam mangle and severely injured her fingers. Though she was still able to play the harmonium in chapel, the days of making great music were gone.

Sister Corinne then turned to the harmonies of French, obtaining her ma from the

down up



University of Toronto and her PhD from Laval in 1952 with a thesis entitled “Romain Rolland et la musique.” Her love of harmony helped at least one student complete her course assignments. “We seniors were working on papers up to here. Well, she let me, instead of writing a paper, set a couple of poems [to music]. Not even a full musical setting, just a tune (my musical concepts are only hunt and peck). They sure sounded nice when she played them with two hands. And she explained about home tones. What a dear!”5 Though music remained her first love, Sister Corinne was in tune with the teaching of French and encouraged all her students, from beginner to advanced. “It was 1954. I arrived at St Michael’s with no previous knowledge in French. So unobtrusively Sr. Corinne began to tutor me once or twice a week. I did not realize until much, much later that I was learning not just French, but also from her the qualities of enthusiasm,

down up



love and serenity that she so beautifully personified.”6 She was able to recognize the potential in her students and to encourage them to perform to their maximum capacity. When Patricia Purcell wrote a paper on Anne Hébert in her fourth year, Sister Corinne arranged for it to appear in an issue of Canadian Literature,7 thus launching a fine career, for Patricia Purcell Smart has since written many works on Quebec literature, including the 1988 Governor General’s Award-winning essay Écrire dans la maison du père.8 After seven years spent as superior general of her community and a sabbatical year in France, Sister Corinne returned to St Michael’s in 1975 but was forced by ill health to resign four years later.

Having obtained his ba and ma from the University of Toronto, G. Donal O’Gorman pursued studies at Columbia University under the direction of Otis E.

down up



Fellows, obtaining his PhD in 1960. After passionate discussions with colleagues and many years’ work he published a greatly revised version of his thesis, Diderot the Satirist (1971), which caused quite a critical stir. While he continued to publish articles on Diderot, his research interests were wide-ranging, including Voltaire’s Candide, Henry James’s Turn of the Screw, and Marcel Dubé’s Les Beaux Dimanches. Father O’Gorman’s enthusiasm carried over into his teaching at both the undergraduate and graduate levels and into the years he spent as discipline representative. But the time came when this work was no longer enough for him, and in 1984 he asked for and received a leave of absence in order to turn his enthusiasm to a new project, the Institute for the Study and Application of Integrated Development (isaid), dedicated to the problems of the poor in developing countries. He subsequently retired from the University of Toronto and became the pastor of a parish in Lethbridge, Alberta.

down up



Mother Mary Bernadette (Mary Culman), who had been a student of Mother Olga, obtained her ba and ma at the University of Toronto. During the few years she spent at St Michael’s College, she taught language-practice courses, as well as filling the position of dean of residence at Loretto College. Sister M. Eleanor (Loretto Breen) studied at St Joseph’s College. After attending the Ontario College of Education, she entered St Joseph’s Novitiate in 1931 and spent many years teaching high school French at St Joseph’s College School and other venues before doing graduate work at Université Laval. After defending a PhD thesis in 1959 on “Le Réalisme dans Georges Duhamel,” she was hired by St Michael’s College, where her lectures were peppered with anecdotes gathered during a year spent in France. She made her students see, through her eyes, the glories of the châteaux of the Loire and the enchantingly lit paintings of Georges

down up



de la Tour at the Louvre. These and many other digressions were as much part of her courses as Descartes and Pascal. Sister Eleanor was an enthusiastic teacher of part-time students and was appointed honorary fellow of Woodsworth College, the University of Toronto’s college for part-time students. When the Hon. Pauline McGibbon was sworn in as chancellor of the University of Toronto, Sister Eleanor was asked to say the opening prayer at convocation, the first woman to have had this privilege.

Kevin Kirley graduated from St Michael’s College in Modern History and Modern Languages in 1949, and his yearbook motto was “goodness, discipline, knowledge.” After joining the Basilians and being ordained, thus taking care of “goodness” and “discipline,” he continued his pursuit of “knowledge” in France before returning to Toronto. “After nine years in France, 1953-1962, first as a

down up



graduate student in Paris and Lyon, and then as a teacher in the classical college in Annonay, it was a relatively simple matter to stand before groups of students at St Michael’s in 1962 and lecture in French. I was used to examining French in the light of English and vice versa, so that grammar and conversation classes were pleasant teaching experiences for me in those years 1962-1967.” Not only did Father Kirley find delight in teaching, he even claims to have enjoyed departmental meetings. “I think we were a happy department, by and large, we looked forward to our department meetings, imagine! because it gave us a chance to be together for a brief while, we who enjoyed so much in common.” Though he was enjoying his work in Toronto, Kevin Kirley’s tenure in the department was to be brief. As he described it, “The first two years of teaching on the university level kept me very busy preparing lectures and correcting written work ... I was just

down up



about ready to teach in earnest when fate or fortune directed my steps back to France to my old teaching post in Annonay.”

It was to Annonay that Father Donovan turned when he realized that the department needed to expand, and he asked Basilian confrères who were then studying in Lyon, not far from the Basilian motherhouse in Annonay, for help in finding staff. They recommended Philippe Lafaury, who was not only an outstanding student at the Université de Lyon but was actually willing to teach in the far-away city of Toronto. Lafaury was the first lay professor of French recruited by St Michael’s directly from France and the first lay person to teach in the department for any length of time; Philippe’s wife, Geneviève Lafaury, was the second. Along with his degrees and his youthful enthusiasm, Philippe Lafaury

down up



brought with him recipes for culinary wonders whose fragrant odours would waft for many years through Department of French offices, adding a great deal of spice to our days. In addition to serving as discipline representative from 1981 to 1985 and again from 1986 to 1988, Lafaury was, for many years, responsible for the St Michael’s language laboratory, which he founded in 1971 in what is now Phelan House. He created an impressive audio-visual library for classroom use and pioneered the installation of computers for the study of language.

During this period, yet another religious from Loretto College, Sister Magdala Grisé, joined the St Michael’s staff. Catherine Grisé had received all her degrees from the University of Toronto, and her PhD thesis, completed in 1964 and entitled “The Lyric Poetry of Tristan L’Hermite,” was written under the

down up



supervision of Victor E. Graham.9 The same year she began teaching at St Michael’s. She has always been able to establish a good rapport with her students, whether garbed in religious habit or in lay clothes after she left the convent. She has published extensively in her field, including two critical editions of Tristan L’Hermite and a book entitled Under the Pear Tree: Patterns of Deception in La Fontaine’s Contes. Her research interests also include aesthetics, rhetoric, and narrativity as they relate to poetry, the cognitive dimension of literature, and irony. This last interest has served her well over the years since she has held a number of important administrative posts, ranging from discipline representative at St Michael’s College to associate chair, undergraduate (1981-83), acting chair of the department (1983 and 1984-85), and associate dean of the Faculty of Arts and Science (1990-93).

down up



A lively member of the department during this period was Robert Fink, who obtained his ba and ma from the University of Toronto and his PhD from Chicago in 1971 with a thesis entitled “Les Premières Oeuvres de Jacques Pelletier du Mans.” While he was working on the final stages of his thesis in Paris, he found time to socialize with University of Toronto colleagues whom he ran into at the Bibliothèque Nationale. As he wrote in a letter, “Comme toujours il y a des tas de Torontois à Paris – Merrilees, McLelland [sic], Oliver, Gilbert, ... John Wood, Laure Rièse et al. Denis St-Jacques est parti, ainsi que ... Paulette [Collet]. Je n’ai pas encore vu les Thépot.”10 Fink’s many interests included cinema, especially the French Nouvelle Vague, and photography. His slide shows for the Cercle Français, which combined erudition and wit, charmed students and helped them understand the architectural wonders of France.

down up



Three new staff members were appointed to the college in 1966. Catherine Holmes, originally from Winnipeg, completed her doctorate in Paris under the direction of Antoine Adam. Her thesis on an unusual topic, L’Éloquence judiciaire de 1620 à 1660, was published by Nizet in 1967. In the short time she spent at the University of Toronto, Holmes provided a great deal of intellectual stimulation. She conscienciously read the latest books and always shared her discoveries with colleagues and students. Peter Fitting, a graduate of St Mary’s College, California, and the University of Minnesota, obtained his PhD in 1969 from Harvard with a thesis entitled “Bernanos and the Problem of the Novel.” His research interests have been varied, including twentieth-century French literature, sociocritique, Marxism, science fiction, and utopias. In 1979 Fitting was cross-appointed to New College, where he was already very much involved in

down up



the college programme.

At the Ma and PhD levels at the University of Toronto, Mariel O’Neill-Karch, another St Michael’s recruit in 1966, had concentrated on courses related to theatre, ranging from medieval theatre with Robert Harden, through Racine with Sister Olga and mise en scène with Clarence Parsons, to Modern Drama with Laure Rièse. After joining the staff, her focus shifted first to nineteenth-century French literature, especially George Sand, Gérard de Nerval, and Baudelaire, then to Quebec literature. She produced an anthology entitled Options in 1974 with P.P. Karch and several articles before returning to her first love, theatre, with courses on Quebec theatre and the emerging Franco-Ontarian corpus, which she analysed in a book, Théâtre franco-ontarien: espaces ludiques (1992).


down up



Another colleague at St Michael’s College has not only published in the field of theatre but has also directed numerous student productions at the college. Paulette Collet, born in Belgium and schooled in England, taught in Mauritius and the United States before going to Université Laval to do graduate work. She obtained her MA in 1961 with a thesis entitled “Les Sensations dans le roman de Langevin.” Though she wrote her PhD thesis on L’Hiver dans le roman canadien-français,11 a decidedly cool topic, her teaching exuded a great deal of warmth, as these adjectives, taken from student evaluations, show: “dynamic, enthusiastic, fascinating, and approachable.”12 Her background led her to explore the contributions to Canadian literature made by transplanted or visiting Europeans, the topic of several books and articles, and to a course on francophone literature from Western Canada. Paulette Collet served for several

down up



years as the college’s discipline representative. But her most original contribution to the Department of French has been theatrical. Almost every year from 1970 (the only exceptions being her sabbaticals), she mounted a French play, usually by Molière, at various venues, most recently at St Michael’s College. Before the creation of a permanent theatre at St Michael’s, they were staged in a classroom-cum-auditorium at Victoria College. Always a major undertaking, the plays attracted full houses to quasi-professional productions.13

A Belgian compatriot, Derrick de Kerckhove, has also greatly influenced the life of the college. After undergraduate studies at the University of Ottawa and Toronto, he obtained two doctorates, one from the University of Toronto in 1975 with a thesis, “Le Sentiment du tragique dans les premières tragédies de Voltaire,


down up



” directed by George Trembley, and a second from the Université François-Rabelais in Tours four years later, where his thesis was entitled “Esquisse d’une sociologie sensorielle de la tragédie grecque: l’exemple d’Eschyle.” He was appointed to St Michael’s College in 1969. De Kerckhove has won numerous awards and grants for his work on media and culture, arts and communication technologies, and neuro-cultural research, and since 1972 he has been associated in various capacities, ranging from associate researcher to co-director, with the McLuhan Programme in Culture and Technology. His scholarly and professional work is far-reaching and ranges from translations into French of seminal works of Marshall McLuhan to articles, papers, and books on language, literacy and new technologies, transinteractivity, multi-media performances, and televised publicity. Among his publications is La Civilisation vidéo-chrétienne, brought out in Paris in 1991.

down up



Somewhat older manifestations of Christianity have interested Peter Grillo, who studied at Harvard University, obtaining his PhD in 1969 with a thesis on “The Old French Continuations of the Conquête de Jérusalem.” The same year he joined the staff of St Michael’s College. He has continued to probe more deeply into his subject and has published well-received scholarly editions of medieval texts that are part of the Old French crusade cycle, the Jerusalem Continuations. La Chrétienté Corbaran appeared in 1984 and La Prise d’Acre, La Mort de Godefroi and La Chanson des rois Baudoin in 1987.

François Des Roches, after graduating from the Université de Montréal, obtained his doctorat du troisième cycle from the Université de Strasbourg, where he wrote a thesis entitled “L’Expression poétique de Saint-Denys Garneau.” Hired as St Michael’s first linguist that year, at a time when interest in linguistics was growing

down up



in the department, Des Roches created a course on French-Canadian language that became very popular. He also occasionally taught Quebec literature, especially poetry. Another recruit in 1970 was Jacqueline Hanna. After obtaining a certificat d’études littéraires générales from the Sorbonne, she was awarded an ma from Boston University in 1968. She returned to Paris to teach at the École de l’Alliance Française. In 1969 she came to Toronto and taught briefly for the Ontario government before taking a position at St Michael’s College, where she was a lecturer from 1970 to 1977 and then a senior tutor from 1977. She has taught many appreciative students the full range of language courses, several in the field of translation, and a very successful course in Francophonie, which she created. From 1980 to 1983 she was the co-ordinator for French courses offered through the School of Continuing Studies, including those of the Summer School at Saint-Pierre.

down up



During the sixties and early seventies, one of the major factors contributing to a congenial atmosphere in the department was the French House (now Phelan House) on Elmsley Place, where most members had their offices. On the ground floor, the parlour was first occupied by Father Bondy, then by Catherine Holmes, the conservatory housed the language lab, Donal O’Gorman presided in the dining-room, and Paulette Collet received in the kitchen. The second-floor master bedroom was reserved for the chairman, Richard Donovan, who surrounded himself by younger staff. To the right of the stairs was Bernard Clérin, who opted to do his military service drilling students in French verbs, before taking a job at Radio-Canada. His office was later occupied by Sister Marie-Thérèse. To the left of the chairman’s suite, a pleasant room with a fireplace and several desks was used at various times by Gisèle Kayser, a St Michael’s College graduate who

down up



obtained her ma in 1964 from the University of Toronto; Thérèse Villatte, a Parisian agrégation student; Marie-Madeleine Thépot, who had a French doctorate in anthropology; all of whom kept Mariel O’Neill company. The next two offices were those of Philippe Lafaury and Peter Grillo.

Up the servants’ stairs, several colleagues were installed tant bien que mal, the most incongruous accommodation being that of Robert Fink, who did what he could to mask the fact that he was ensconced in the former bathroom. With him on the third floor at various times were several other staff members, including Peter Fitting, Derrick de Kerckhove, Denis Saint-Jacques, Françoise Khettry, Joseph Sablé, Germaine Laurens, and Jacqueline Hanna. Some of these lively attic dwellers did not stay at St Michael’s long. Saint-Jacques, a specialist in Québécois literature with wide interests and many connections, went back to

down up



Quebec to assume a position at Laval. The inimitable Germaine Laurens taught oral and phonetic classes. Her booming voice and infectious laugh echoed through the halls of the French House and of the faculty dining-room, where almost all members of the French Department used to congregate at noon – much to the chagrin of some of the more conservative Basilians, who had a little trouble digesting so much French.

Last, but by no means least, Joseph Sablé, a secular priest from Paris’s prestigious Institut Catholique, helped bridge the gap between the French House, where he had an office during a term as visiting professor in 1968-69, and Elmsley Hall, where the department was to locate when he returned, with a regular appointment, in 1971. Father Sablé was known for his thunderous

down up



lectures, very much in the tradition of Leonard Rush, and for his untiring devotion to his students. His greatest contribution to the college and to the department was his gift to the John M. Kelly Library of a major research collection of nineteenth-century French romanticism known as the Sablé Collection, including priceless books, manuscripts, and artifacts. Both his generosity and his erudition were recognized by the college in the fall of 1992, when he was awarded a doctorate honoris causa, and by the department in 1993, when the chairman recommended that he be made a chevalier de la Légion d’honneur.

In 1971 the French House was converted into a residence for Basilians, and the French Department moved to Elmsley Hall, which at that time housed male college residents on the fourth floor, along with colleagues in German, Classics,

down up



and English. The French Department’s second-floor quarters were more democratic, since the offices were identical, but it took several years to recreate, in this homogeneous space, the heterogeneous creativity of the old French House.

The first person hired after the move was Jean-Claude Susini, who had obtained his licence and des from the Université de Montpellier and in 1962 his agrégation de grammaire in Paris. He then taught at French lycées in Alès, Nîmes, and Bordeaux and at the University of New York at Albany, before coming to St Michael’s College in 1971. Most of Susini’s publications deal with aspects of the poetry of Baudelaire, and his enthusiasm for both nineteenth- and twentieth-century literature has infused his very successful courses on French romanticism and the twentieth-century novel. He has also shared with several groups of fortunate students the history and culture of his beloved Midi, since he

down up



served as director of the department’s Third Year Elsewhere programme at Aix-en-Provence for a record four years. In his Toronto office, North American antiques and folk art have greeted students and colleagues in what has become, over the years, a veritable salon for the display of wit and the exchange of ideas. Another French expatriate hired the same year, Françoise Khettry, obtained her licence from the Université de Strasbourg and her ma and PhD from the University of Toronto. Her thesis, completed in 1976 under the direction of Peter Moes, studied the “Évolution de la conception de l’amour conjugal dans la comédie française de Molière à Beaumarchais.” Though it was on a literary topic, she was soon attracted to linguistics, especially the sociolinguistics of French as spoken by people in her native Alsace. Her interest in orthoépie led her to develop new materials for the undergraduate course in this field. Her administrative contributions to the department include serving for two years

down up



as director for study at Laval and as discipline representative for Woodsworth College from 1987 to 1992.

The last person appointed to the St Michael’s French Department before 1975 was, appropriately, a Basilian. Charles Principe did his undergraduate work in arts and theology at St Michael’s College and his ma at the University of Toronto. In France he obtained a licence from the Université de Lyon and his doctorate from the Sorbonne in 1978. His thesis, “Les Portraits du sauvage dans les Relations de la Nouvelle-France écrites par le Père Paul Le Jeune de 1632 à 1642,” was awarded the Sainte-Marie Prize that year. An archivist at heart, Principe has photographed almost all of the groups of students he taught, carefully noting their names so that he would recognize them at alumni gatherings. He has been equally interested in his colleagues, serving a term as discipline

down up



representative, sending postcards from his trips back to France, especially from Annonay, where he taught for several years, and discretely helping in many ways colleagues who fell ill. In his own way, he has been the very heart of the department.14









up